Examining Systemic Factors in Psychiatric Inpatient Violence: A Call for Broader Clinical Assessment

Jaafar, Azmi Abdulhussein

doi:10.32894/kjms.2025.160670.1161

Examining Systemic Factors in Psychiatric Inpatient Violence: A Call for Broader Clinical Assessment

Document Type : Letter to Editor

Author

Azmi Abdulhussein Jaafar

Mental Health Professional, Department of Health, Center for Social Emotional Wellbeing – Refugee, Women’s Alliance, Washington, USA

https://doi.org/10.32894/kjms.2025.160670.1161

Abstract

This letter responds to a recent study on violence among schizophrenic inpatients at Al-Rashad Training Hospital. While commending the authors’ important contribution, the letter highlights key areas needing further attention to strengthen the findings. It discusses the exclusion of female patients, the limitations of a cross-sectional design, and the need to analyze systemic factors such as staffing, training, and ward environment. The letter advocates for the use of comprehensive diagnostic and risk assessment tools beyond standard criteria to better understand symptom patterns and predict aggression. Suggestions include using validated scales like PANSS, BPRS, and HCR-20. The author calls for broader, longitudinal research that considers gender differences, symptom severity, and institutional variables to improve patient care and safety. By addressing these gaps, future studies can provide stronger evidence to guide clinical practice and policy in psychiatric inpatient settings.

Keywords

Schizophrenia

Inpatient violence

Forensic psychiatry

Risk assessment

Psychiatric hospital environment

Subjects